Impact of 85% Cocoa Dark Chocolate on Mood and Gut Microbiota: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Table of Contents

Overall Summary

Overview

The study investigates how daily consumption of dark chocolate, specifically 85% cocoa, affects mood and gut bacteria in healthy adults aged 20-30. Conducted as a randomized controlled trial, participants were assigned to consume either 85% or 70% cocoa chocolate or no chocolate for three weeks. The research aimed to explore the potential mood-boosting effects of dark chocolate, focusing on the gut-brain axis, a concept describing the communication between the gut and brain through bacteria. Mood was measured using a standardized psychological tool, while gut bacteria were analyzed using advanced genetic sequencing. The study found that 85% cocoa chocolate significantly improved mood and increased gut bacterial diversity, suggesting dark chocolate acts like a prebiotic, encouraging beneficial gut bacteria growth.

Key Findings

Strengths

Areas for Improvement

Significant Elements

flow diagram

Description: This diagram outlines the participant selection and randomization process, showing no dropouts during the study.

Relevance: Ensures transparency in participant management and highlights the study's methodological rigor.

figure

Description: Figure 2 depicts changes in gut bacterial diversity and specific bacteria after 85% cocoa chocolate consumption.

Relevance: Visually supports the hypothesis that dark chocolate alters gut microbiota, underpinning mood improvements.

Conclusion

The study provides compelling evidence that 85% cocoa dark chocolate can improve mood and diversify gut bacteria, possibly acting as a prebiotic. These findings highlight a novel approach to mood regulation through diet, specifically targeting the gut-brain axis. Future research should explore the mechanisms underlying these effects, incorporate placebo-controlled designs, and examine long-term impacts. This research has potential practical applications for dietary interventions aimed at improving mental health through natural food products like dark chocolate.

Section Analysis

Abstract

Overview

This abstract summarizes a randomized controlled trial investigating the effects of daily dark chocolate consumption on mood, particularly focusing on the connection between gut bacteria and the brain. The study involved healthy adults aged 20-30 who consumed either 85% cocoa chocolate (DC85), 70% cocoa chocolate (DC70), or no chocolate (control group) for three weeks. The results showed that consuming 85% cocoa dark chocolate daily significantly reduced negative emotions in the DC85 group but not in the DC70 group. Analysis of gut bacteria revealed that the DC85 group had a more diverse gut microbiome and higher levels of a specific bacterium called Blautia obeum compared to the control group. The study suggests that dark chocolate, particularly with higher cocoa content, may act as a prebiotic, promoting the growth of beneficial gut bacteria, which in turn could positively influence mood.

Key Aspects

Strengths

Suggestions for Improvement

Introduction

Overview

This introduction sets the stage for a study investigating the effects of dark chocolate on mood, particularly focusing on its potential influence on gut bacteria and their connection to the brain. It starts by highlighting the prevalence of mood disorders and the limitations of current treatments. Then, it introduces the concept of diet, specifically dark chocolate, as a potential mood regulator due to its rich nutritional content, especially polyphenols. The introduction further delves into the emerging understanding of the gut microbiome's role in brain function and mood regulation, emphasizing the gut-brain axis as a potential target for mood disorder treatment. Finally, it proposes the hypothesis that dark chocolate's beneficial effects on mood might be linked to its ability to positively alter the composition of gut bacteria.

Key Aspects

Strengths

Suggestions for Improvement

Materials and methods

Overview

This section describes the design and procedures of a randomized controlled trial investigating the effects of dark chocolate consumption on mood and gut microbiota in healthy adults. The study involved three groups: a control group consuming no chocolate, a group consuming 85% cocoa dark chocolate, and a group consuming 70% cocoa dark chocolate. Participants consumed 30 grams of chocolate daily for three weeks. The study measured mood using the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule (PANAS) and analyzed gut microbiota composition through fecal sample analysis. Body composition and dietary intake were also assessed before and after the intervention. The section details the recruitment and randomization of participants, the intervention protocol, and the methods used for data collection and analysis.

Key Aspects

Strengths

Suggestions for Improvement

Results

Overview

This section presents the findings of the study, starting with the participant characteristics and then detailing the effects of dark chocolate consumption on mood and gut microbiota. The researchers found no significant differences in anthropometric parameters or dietary intake between the groups after the three-week intervention. However, daily consumption of 85% cocoa dark chocolate (DC85) led to a significant decrease in negative affect, while the 70% cocoa dark chocolate (DC70) group showed no significant change compared to the control group. Further analysis revealed that the DC85 group experienced an increase in gut microbial diversity, particularly evident in Faith's phylogenetic diversity and the number of observed operational taxonomic units (OTUs). Additionally, the DC85 group showed a significant increase in the abundance of Blautia obeum and a decrease in Faecalibacterium prausnitzii. Finally, the researchers found a negative correlation between negative affect scores and both the number of observed OTUs and the relative abundance of Blautia obeum.

Key Aspects

Strengths

Suggestions for Improvement

Non-Text Elements

flow diagram 1

This flow diagram visually represents the journey of participants through the different stages of the research study. It starts with the initial enrollment of 117 candidates who were interested in participating. After screening these candidates based on specific criteria, 48 participants were deemed eligible and agreed to take part in the study. These 48 participants were then randomly divided into three groups: 14 participants in the control group (CON), 18 participants in the 85% cocoa chocolate group (DC85), and 16 participants in the 70% cocoa chocolate group (DC70). All participants in each group completed the three-week intervention, meaning they followed the study's instructions for the entire duration. Finally, the data collected from all 48 participants was analyzed to understand the effects of dark chocolate consumption.

First Mention

Text: "as presented in the flow diagram of the intervention study (Fig. 1)"

Context: A total of 48 eligible participants who consented to participate in the study were randomly assigned to one of the following three groups, as presented in the flow diagram of the intervention study (Fig. 1): Control (CON, n = 14); 85% dark chocolate (DC85, n = 18); and 70% dark chocolate (DC70, n = 16).

Relevance: This flow diagram is crucial for understanding how the researchers ensured a fair and unbiased comparison between the different chocolate consumption groups. It clearly shows the steps taken to select participants, randomly assign them to groups, and track their progress throughout the study, ensuring that the final analysis includes data from all participants who completed the intervention.

Critique
Visual Aspects
  • The diagram effectively uses boxes and arrows to represent the different stages of the study and the flow of participants.
  • The number of participants in each group at each stage is clearly indicated within the boxes.
  • The diagram is clean and easy to follow, allowing readers to quickly grasp the study's design.
Analytical Aspects
  • The diagram clearly demonstrates the randomized controlled trial design, which is a strong approach for investigating cause-and-effect relationships.
  • The inclusion of the initial screening stage highlights the researchers' efforts to select a specific group of participants (healthy adults aged 20-30) to ensure the study's relevance to the target population.
  • The diagram emphasizes the completion of the intervention by all participants, indicating good adherence to the study protocol and strengthening the reliability of the results.
Numeric Data
  • Initial Candidates: 117
  • Eligible Participants: 48
  • Control Group (CON): 14 participants
  • 85% Cocoa Chocolate Group (DC85): 18 participants
  • 70% Cocoa Chocolate Group (DC70): 16 participants
table 1

This table provides a snapshot of the key characteristics of the participants at the beginning of the study, before they started consuming any chocolate. It's like a class roster with extra details about each student. The table is divided into three columns, representing the three groups of participants: the control group (CON), the 85% cocoa chocolate group (DC85), and the 70% cocoa chocolate group (DC70). Each row in the table represents a different characteristic of the participants, such as their age, weight, body mass index (BMI), muscle mass, body fat, and their usual daily intake of calories, carbohydrates, fats, and proteins. The numbers in the table show the average value for each characteristic within each group, along with a measure of how much the values vary within the group (standard deviation). The last column, labeled 'P value', tells us whether there are any significant differences between the groups for each characteristic. A small P value (less than 0.05) suggests that the groups are likely different in that specific characteristic.

First Mention

Text: "The general characteristics of the study subjects at baseline are shown in Table 1"

Context: The general characteristics of the study subjects at baseline are shown in Table 1. At baseline, there were no significant differences in sex ratio (P = .903), age (P = .603), weight (P = .603), BMI (P = .601), skeletal muscle mass (P = .592), body fat mass (P = .447), or percent body fat (P = .927) across the three groups.

Relevance: This table is important because it shows that the three groups of participants were similar in their key characteristics before the study began. This means that any differences observed between the groups after the three-week intervention are more likely due to the chocolate consumption rather than pre-existing differences between the groups.

Critique
Visual Aspects
  • The table is well-organized and easy to read, with clear labels for each row and column.
  • The use of mean and standard deviation provides a good summary of the data for each characteristic.
  • The inclusion of the P value column helps readers quickly identify any significant differences between the groups.
Analytical Aspects
  • The table effectively demonstrates that the randomization process successfully created groups that were comparable at baseline.
  • The lack of significant differences between the groups for most characteristics strengthens the study's internal validity, suggesting that the observed effects are likely due to the intervention.
  • The table provides valuable context for interpreting the results, allowing readers to understand the characteristics of the participants and how they might influence the study's findings.
Numeric Data
  • Average Age (CON): 22.86 years
  • Average Age (DC85): 24.94 years
  • Average Age (DC70): 24.06 years
  • Average Weight (CON): 63.27 kg
  • Average Weight (DC85): 66.16 kg
  • Average Weight (DC70): 66.3 kg
  • Average BMI (CON): 22.29 kg/m^2
  • Average BMI (DC85): 22.37 kg/m^2
  • Average BMI (DC70): 22.66 kg/m^2
figure Fig. 2

This figure illustrates the impact of consuming 85% cocoa dark chocolate on the diversity and composition of gut bacteria. It uses violin plots to show the distribution of data for different diversity indices and the Firmicutes-to-Bacteroidetes ratio, and bar graphs to compare the relative abundance of specific bacteria species between the control and chocolate groups.

First Mention

Text: "Differences in the alpha diversity of the gut microbial community between baseline and the end of the intervention were measured and compared between the DC85 and CON groups (Fig. 2 A-C)."

Context: This sentence introduces Figure 2 in the context of comparing the diversity of gut bacteria between the control group and the group consuming 85% cocoa dark chocolate.

Relevance: This figure is crucial for visualizing the study's key findings regarding the prebiotic effects of dark chocolate. It demonstrates how consuming 85% cocoa dark chocolate can increase the diversity of gut bacteria and alter the abundance of specific species, which might be linked to the observed mood improvements.

Critique
Visual Aspects
  • The violin plots effectively show the data distribution, but adding a dot for each data point within the violins would enhance individual data visibility.
  • The bar graphs are clear, but using a consistent color scheme for the control and chocolate groups across all panels would improve visual consistency.
  • Labeling the y-axis of the bar graphs with 'Relative Abundance' would make the units of measurement clearer.
Analytical Aspects
  • The figure focuses on comparing the chocolate group to the control group, but showing the baseline data for both groups would provide a better understanding of the changes induced by chocolate consumption.
  • Including statistical significance indicators (e.g., asterisks) directly on the plots would make it easier to identify significant differences.
  • The figure mentions the Firmicutes-to-Bacteroidetes ratio, but briefly explaining its relevance to gut health and mood in the caption would make the figure more accessible to a broader audience.
Numeric Data
  • Faith's PD (DC85):
  • Faith's PD (CON):
  • Number of Observed OTUs (DC85):
  • Number of Observed OTUs (CON):
  • Shannon's H index (DC85):
  • Shannon's H index (CON):
  • Firmicutes-to-Bacteroidetes ratio (DC85):
  • Firmicutes-to-Bacteroidetes ratio (CON):
  • Relative Abundance of Blautia obeum (DC85):
  • Relative Abundance of Blautia obeum (CON):
  • Relative Abundance of Faecalibacterium prausnitzii (DC85):
  • Relative Abundance of Faecalibacterium prausnitzii (CON):
table Table 2

This table presents the changes in mood scores, specifically positive and negative affect, before and after the three-week intervention period for the three study groups: control (CON), 85% cocoa chocolate (DC85), and 70% cocoa chocolate (DC70). It shows the average scores, standard deviations, and p-values for comparing the changes between groups.

First Mention

Text: "negative affect was significantly altered by dark chocolate consumption (Table 2)."

Context: This sentence introduces Table 2 in the context of discussing the significant impact of dark chocolate consumption on negative affect scores.

Relevance: This table is important because it directly addresses the study's primary research question: Does dark chocolate consumption influence mood? It provides the numerical evidence for the observed changes in mood scores, particularly the significant reduction in negative affect in the DC85 group.

Critique
Visual Aspects
  • The table is clear and well-organized, with clear labels for each group and time point.
  • Using bold font to highlight significant p-values would make them stand out more.
  • Adding a brief explanation of the PANAS scoring system in a footnote would make the table more understandable to a general audience.
Analytical Aspects
  • The table focuses on comparing the changes in mood scores between groups, but including the actual 'Before' and 'After' scores for each group would provide a more complete picture of the mood changes.
  • The table mentions that p-values were corrected for multiple comparisons, but specifying the correction method used would enhance transparency.
  • The table doesn't explicitly state the direction of the significant change in negative affect for the DC85 group. Adding a sentence in the caption clarifying that negative affect scores decreased significantly in the DC85 group would improve clarity.
Numeric Data
  • Positive Affect Change (CON): 1.11
  • Positive Affect Change (DC85): 1.95
  • Positive Affect Change (DC70): 0.059
  • Negative Affect Change (CON): 0.296
  • Negative Affect Change (DC85): -4.33
  • Negative Affect Change (DC70): -1.83
figure 3

Figure 3 illustrates the relationship between changes in gut bacteria and mood after consuming 85% dark chocolate. It has three parts: A heatmap showing correlations between gut bacteria measures and mood scores, a scatter plot showing the link between bacterial diversity and negative mood, and another scatter plot showing the link between Blautia obeum abundance and negative mood.

First Mention

Text: "To investigate the link between the gut microbiota and host mood, we conducted Spearman’s correlation analysis between bacterial diversity and significantly altered taxa and PANAS scores (Fig. 3 A)."

Context: This sentence introduces the purpose of Figure 3, which is to explore the connection between gut bacteria changes and mood using a statistical method called Spearman's correlation analysis.

Relevance: This figure is crucial because it visually represents the study's main finding: a potential link between dark chocolate's effect on gut bacteria and its mood-boosting effect. It helps us see if changes in specific bacteria types are related to changes in how people feel.

Critique
Visual Aspects
  • The heatmap in part A could be more intuitive by using a color scheme that clearly distinguishes positive and negative correlations. For example, a gradient from blue (negative) to red (positive) would be easier to interpret.
  • The scatter plots in parts B and C would benefit from larger data points and clearer labels for the axes. This would make the trends easier to see.
  • Adding a brief caption explaining what Spearman's correlation coefficient (r) represents would make the figure more accessible to a wider audience.
Analytical Aspects
  • While the figure shows correlations, it's important to remember that correlation doesn't equal causation. The figure alone can't prove that dark chocolate directly causes mood changes through gut bacteria.
  • The figure focuses on negative mood. Showing similar analyses for positive mood would provide a more complete picture of dark chocolate's effects.
  • Including confidence intervals or error bars in the scatter plots would give a better sense of the uncertainty around the correlations.
Numeric Data
  • Correlation between F/B ratio and positive affect: -0.425
  • P-value for correlation between F/B ratio and positive affect: 0.017
  • Correlation between number of observed OTUs and negative affect: -0.402
  • P-value for correlation between number of observed OTUs and negative affect: 0.025
  • Correlation between Blautia obeum abundance and negative affect: -0.383
  • P-value for correlation between Blautia obeum abundance and negative affect: 0.034

Discussion

Overview

This section discusses the study's findings in the context of existing research on dark chocolate's effects on mood and the gut-brain axis. The authors highlight the novelty of their study in examining the impact of daily dark chocolate consumption on mood in everyday life, as opposed to previous studies that focused on acute effects under stressful conditions. They discuss the potential dose-dependent effect of cocoa on mood, as only the 85% cocoa group showed significant improvements. The authors then delve into the role of gut microbial diversity and specific bacterial taxa in mood regulation, connecting their findings to previous research. They propose that dark chocolate's prebiotic effects, leading to changes in gut microbiota composition, might be responsible for the observed mood benefits. The discussion also explores the potential mechanisms by which polyphenols in dark chocolate could influence mood, both directly and indirectly through modulation of the gut microbiome. Finally, the authors acknowledge limitations of their study, such as the lack of blinding in the control group and the reliance on self-reported mood assessments, and suggest directions for future research.

Key Aspects

Strengths

Suggestions for Improvement

Conclusions

Overview

This conclusion section summarizes the key findings of the study, emphasizing the potential prebiotic effects of dark chocolate and its impact on mood through the gut-brain axis. The authors reiterate that daily consumption of 85% cocoa dark chocolate led to a reduction in negative affect and was associated with changes in gut microbial diversity and composition. They highlight the novelty of their findings as the first to demonstrate the influence of daily dark chocolate consumption on both physiological and psychological states. The conclusion suggests that dark chocolate's ability to restructure the gut microbiome might contribute to its mood-improving effects.

Key Aspects

Strengths

Suggestions for Improvement

↑ Back to Top